Even Odds Pizza, 372 Falls Rd in Grafton

4.4 - 5 votes
  • 372 Falls Rd
  • (262) 376-0420
  • website

Even Odds Pizza on map


Su 10:00 - 24:00
Mo 10:00 - 24:00
Tu 10:00 - 24:00
We 10:00 - 24:00
Th 10:00 - 24:00
Fr 10:00 - 24:00
Sa 10:00 - 24:00

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.

More Info

  • Parking: Private Lot
All menu


  • Google 5
  • Facebook 5
  • Yelp 5
  • Foursquare 1
  • Tripadvisor 5

Take-Out/Delivery Options

delivery take-out


takes reservations caters accepts credit cards wi-fi


Alan Wysocki
Delicious pizza, great staff, delivery and clean store!
July 2020
Gloria S
I'm from Detroit and have lots of pizza there. The Detroit pizza at Even Odds Pizza is delicious.. I will definitely go back, better than I remember from my days in Detroit.
June 2020
Shawn Severson
Pizza i guess is a hit and miss kinda business. Some like it and some don't. It wasn't my acquired taste. I have much better. Tomasos in cedarburg has the bar set hi. Just saying.....
June 2020
Nik K.
The pizza and cheese bread were tasty but the attention to details while it was made was missing. You can tell that it was half-assed by the preparer. First the ingredients were poorly spread out on both, second somehow random raw onions ended up scattered on the pizza while it wasn't one of the ingredients, third random pieces of black olives also somehow ended up on random places. Some edges were so huge without any sauce or cheese that it was clear that nobody paid attention to preparing pizza. It was also cut very half-assed. Some slices were double the size of others. Cheese bread had cheese poorly spread with some pieces being just bread. While ingredients were good, the quality was poor. Management should really review the preparation process.
May 2020
Bryan Johnson
Good pizza, worst service ever. Placed online order and was told 20 mins. Arrived in 30 mins, 6 people in waiting area and after 10 mins of being ignored I asked for my order. He had to look for it. After another 5 mins of looking, my order was still in a ribbon of order stickers waiting to be processed. I cancelled my order.
May 2020
Sheri Brown
First time ordering and OMG the pizza is so good. Got the Meat T with the hand tossed crust, garlic bread with cheese and Peanut Butter cheesecake. TBH we haven't tried the cheesecake yet because we are full from the delicious pizza & garlic bread. Will definitely order again.
May 2020
Jeremy C.
Worst experience! Ordered salads which would quick and easy for delivery. An hour and half later, I called to check on order. I got, "it's coming out the oven now sir". I said then the order is completely [email protected]#ked up since they are salads. I asked for the manager. There wasn't one. This is the last straw with them. We've had pizza piled into the corner of the box, numerous times the order has been incorrect. The first couple years when they opened, it was great. Food, service , and quality. Now, it sounds like a halfwitted teen every time you call, and the quality is straight up garbage. The ingredients are cheap, no where near what they were. These owners should be embarrassed as to how this crapshow is run.
May 2020
Jessica J.
As good as it gets on the pizza front! I don't live in this area, so I've never been to Even Odds or tried any of their food. Over the weekend however, my family ordered takeout from here, and it was perfection. I'm not much of a pizza person to be honest, but dang this stuff was good. Among the many pies ordered, I most enjoyed the Big Veg. This za was packed with broccoli, spinach, cauliflower, carrot, corn, mushroom, and artichokes. The crust was the perfect combination of dough and crunch and the cheese was a great blend. I also tried to BBQ Chicken that was ordered. It was bursting with sweet, tangy flavors. Let me tell ya, we ordered a lot of pizza and there wasn't a single piece left by the end of the night. Even Odds also does salads, desserts, wings, and garlic breads. I would look forward to ordering from here again next time I'm in the Cedarbrug area!
May 2020
Candice Mueller
Great pizza! Everytime we get it, we have to order spinach feta garlic bread. To die for!!
May 2020
Just Be Honest, K.
Their pizza can be good IF they don't screw up your order, which they do almost every time. We almost always let it go, but one especially bad error had to be reported. Well, heaven forbid you call to complain. You'll have to talk to the manager, Tomme, and the first thing he'll do is accuse you of lying, before he checks and finds out the truth. No apology; no adjustment. So arrogant and rude, no customer service skills. Same as he used to be at Domino's. They will also charge your CC for items you don't receive. We ordered from them a lot, but not anymore. Plenty of other places.
April 2020
All reviews

Cafes nearby