Old Market House Inn, 424 Market St in Zanesville

4.1 - 5 votes
  • 424 Market St
  • (740) 454-2555
  • website

Old Market House Inn on map


Su Closed
Mo Closed
Tu 4:00 - 21:00
We 4:00 - 21:00
Th 4:00 - 21:00
Fr 4:00 - 21:00
Sa 4:00 - 21:00

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.

More Info

  • Parking: Private Lot
  • Ambience: Classy
  • Noise Level: Quiet
  • Attire: Casual
  • Specialties: Weddings, Bridal Events, Wedding Events, Public


  • Google 4
  • Facebook 4
  • Yelp 4
  • Foursquare 5
  • Tripadvisor 4

Take-Out/Delivery Options



takes reservations accepts credit cards good for kids good for groups good for happy hour has tv wi-fi good for dates dinner family-friendly house salad cocktail sauce


Janet Boehmer
We went while camping with our granddaughter. She wanted Italian. Food was excellent and so was the service.
August 2020
Seth Britt
We spent a hot day in Columbus and stayed in Zanesville for the evening. It was late and we called OMHI if we could still get dinner. It was late and they were close to closing. They welcomed us with open arms and never once rushed us. Great cocktails, AWSOME food and fabulous service. We loved the decor of the stained glass and cathedral work. In the middle of a crazy closing, the manager JESSICA, gave us a personal tour through the whole place. Such a neat place. Worth giving it a try and we’ll for sure find reasons to come back!!
July 2020
David Axline
Great food and drinks. Love this place!
July 2020
DeeDee Bryan
Over priced for what it is. Good food. The place needs a deep cleaning... But the atmosphere is charming.
June 2020
Beth Holtzclaw Garber
OMHI is my first recommendation when someone asks “where’s a good place to eat in this town?” They never disappoint!
April 2020
Vanessa Minner
I hate to leave bad reviews and it even worse because its local owned. I like to support local businesses usually. But as I sit here this very minute in frustration I would like to leave this review. I purchased the seabass dinner which was good but the reason for the poor review is the service. I understand its Valentines day however being seated only took 10 minutes but our food took 1 hour and 45 they stated it was because of being busy however the people around us received food before us and ordered after. Then the waitress said it was because my fish takes long to prepare. She then come over said we will give you free dessert for the long wait. Personally did not want the dessert thanks for the offer just would like overall better service. Still waiting on my bill as I write this entire review so far has taken 15 minutes before someone even come over to ask if we needed anything. For first impression of this restaurant I would not recommend unless you plan on spending 2 hours sitting and waiting.
February 2020
Tammy Gillogly - Hern
Went there on Valentine's night - had very poor service + even worse food. The waitress wasn't friendly at all, we waited on our food for over an hour, when it finally came, it was not worth the wait or the money. Had to ask for our check, so we could finally leave. I don't recommend this place to anyone. We were there for over two hours and got this.
February 2020
Eric S.
Found the Old Market House Inn on Yelp while traveling on the 70. And I'm very happy I did. This a very special restaurant with great food, service and decor. I love it when Yelp leads me to a locally owned and operated restaurant with an extensive menu of high quality food. The meal began with fresh baked bread followed by a fantastic bowl of spaghetti with a delicious meat sauce (house specialty). Had mud pie for dessert. Everything was five stars.
February 2020
Scott Frank
Great food and great service
February 2020
Beverly Rachel
I love the Ambiance of this place, it's cozy and not too bright like restaurants used to be. The food was awesome, the French onion soup and the stuffed mushrooms we're both very good also was the homemade bread soft in the center and a nice crusty outside yum! I had the spicy fettuccine I liked the fact that they make their own pasta you don't get that just anywhere my experience here was great and the service was great as well thank you!
January 2020
All reviews

Cafes nearby