Mattingly's Tavern, 16 N Main St in Florida

4.1 - 5 votes
  • 16 N Main St
  • (845) 508-6675
  • website

Mattingly's Tavern on map


Su 12:00 - 24:00
Mo 12:00 - 24:00
Tu 12:00 - 24:00
We 12:00 - 24:00
Th 12:00 - 24:00
Fr 12:00 - 24:00
Sa 12:00 - 24:00

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.

More Info


  • Google 5
  • Facebook 5
  • Yelp 4
  • Foursquare 1
  • Tripadvisor 1

Take-Out/Delivery Options

delivery take-out


happy hour specials accepts credit cards wheelchair accessible has tv waiter service outdoor seating wi-fi bike parking


Niccole Card
We ordered tonight for the first time and my family was very happy with the food! Great service too! Highly recommend!
August 2020
Meredith Lopez
Very nice staff, incredible service, good drinks. Will come back as a regular, for sure.
August 2020
Michala Miller
Great little bar with great food! Always great service! Highly recommend.
August 2020
K Elliott
I like this spot! They give great meals, their menu is decent, The chef in that restaurant is very trained, I enjoy very much tasting all their dishes. The food is always fresh and tasty, the attitude towards the guests is helpful. I visit often this place and I not even once was unsatisfied. I recommend it to all my friends.
July 2020
Mark C.
We stopped by around 8pm on Father's Day after a hot day of playing golf. We were promptly greeted by Johnny and sat outside due to NY Covid phase. Beer selection was good. We had fried pickles as an appetizer and both of us had steak burgers with fries (like shaved potato skins) which were both excellent. Service was very good and nice banter with our server. Prices are very reasonable. Give them a try. Highly recommended
June 2020
Timothy R.
I've never been inside this place because I only moved here about 3 months ago but the food is pretty good but expensive and small portions. Also they're losing a star for not putting the honey mustard on the sandwich and hiding the fact that the honey mustard isn't homemade. They should try making a homemade honey mustard. This isn't McDonald's or Burger King. Other than those two things, it's not disgusting but it's not the best thing I've tasted. I've tasted a lot worse food.
June 2020
Amanda D.
Tried Mattingly's for the first time this week and loved every part of it! I'm not sure if they always have this special but I got the lunch special; it included 1 appetizer, 2 entrees and two cocktails that came in mason jars for $30. I paid a little extra to get their sampler appetizer to try out a bunch of different items so I know for the next time what to get. The Mac n'Cheese bites and the fried pickles were amazing! I highly suggest trying either of those if that's something you like. For entrees we got two chicken tenders. Seemed fresh and wasn't heavily breaded. The best part of the meal though was the side of "chips" that came with the chicken tenders. Half way between fries and chips, these were delicious. So crispy, so addictive! Honestly the whole meal was just tasty!! For the drinks we got two tequila sunrises and they were good. Very well balanced and by being in the mason jars it was easy to mix real quick to make sure it hadn't separated on the drive back to my house. I also picked up some Jell-O shots and omg, any party I will be having at my house will be having these at it. Honestly can't wait to go back!
May 2020
Megan Torrence Natale
Got the family meal deal tonight with some extras. Food was ready at the pick up time. Burgers were delish, toasted ravioli were crispy and Mac n cheese triangles were yummy. Oh and margaritas were exactly what I needed. Erin was friendly and super helpful. We will definitely get food from here again.
May 2020
Darrin Duurloo
What a great take out experience, not only was the food awesome and at a great price $49, but everyone was so friendly and helpful. I highly recommend ordering! Happy kids and happy adults with some nice mason jar cocktails. Darrin aka(Don)
April 2020
Rob R.
I was traveling on the east coast visiting friends and we had heard from a local that the best wings in town were at mattinglys. So, our group gathered and went and found a table by the bar. The place was awesome. Not only was the food amazing (we ended up having several courses) but the friendly atmosphere and fun staff made the experience top notch. Perfect place for watching sports. Perfect place to hang with buddies. Nice spot for family time. I highly recommend it... I'm coming back soon. Rob R
April 2020
All reviews

Cafes nearby